New Technology / Innovation Policy
Follow innovation policy, technology regulation, industrial strategy and institutional decisions shaping the future of new technology.
Watching the Dragon: How Taiwan Decodes China’s Internal Fragility｜Taiwanology EP.57
Topic
Taiwan's Perspective on China's Internal Dynamics
Key insights
- Chinas increasing opacity complicates the tracking of developments within the country. The great firewall and tighter controls over information hinder firsthand reporting, obscuring the true economic and social conditions
- Despite a reported record trade surplus in 2025, Chinas economic reality is complex. Strong export figures mask underlying issues that require deeper analysis
- The Thinking Taiwan Foundation serves as a public forum for dialogue on Taiwans future, focusing on policy, geopolitical economy, and societal issues related to monitoring China
- Thinking Taiwan 2.0, initiated by former President Tsai Ing-wen, emphasizes long-term trend analysis over day-to-day policymaking. This shift reflects a strategic approach to Taiwans development
- The foundations China Monitoring Project provides insights into Chinas internal dynamics and aims to foster international dialogue, ensuring Taiwans perspectives are recognized globally
- By emphasizing openness and communication, the foundation seeks to engage both domestic and international audiences. This approach is vital for enhancing Taiwans visibility and influence
Perspectives
Analysis of Taiwan's perspective on China's internal dynamics and implications for regional stability.
Taiwan's Insights and Concerns
- Highlights the challenges of understanding China due to increased opacity and information control
- Emphasizes the importance of systematic monitoring of Chinas developments for Taiwans strategic planning
- Argues that Chinas economic model is unsustainable due to reliance on exports and weak domestic consumption
- Warns of rising social unrest in China, reflecting deeper systemic issues rather than isolated economic grievances
- Proposes that Taiwan should strengthen its economic and social resilience to better respond to external pressures
China's Economic and Social Landscape
- Claims that Chinas economy shows dual-speed characteristics with strong exports but weak domestic consumption
- Counters that the Chinese government prioritizes superpower competition over stimulating domestic consumption
- Rejects the notion that low consumer confidence is solely due to security concerns, suggesting broader societal changes
- Accuses the Chinese leadership of ignoring the need for income redistribution to boost domestic demand
Neutral / Shared
- Notes that the Thinking Taiwan Foundation aims to provide insights into Chinas dynamics and foster international dialogue
- Mentions the establishment of the China Monitoring Report to track key indicators across various sectors
Metrics
trade surplus
highest-deferred trade surplus USD
China's economic performance in 2025
A high trade surplus can indicate strong export performance but may mask deeper economic issues.
In 2025, China reported its highest-deferred trade surplus.
other
50 indicators units
total indicators tracked in the report
This breadth allows for a comprehensive view of China's dynamics.
it tracks 50 indicators
other
15 indicators under five categories units
number of indicators currently used
These categories help structure the analysis of China's situation.
we have 15 indicators under five categories
other
more than 50 lectures units
lectures held to discuss various aspects of China
This engagement enriches the research team's understanding.
we have held more than 50 lectures
other
50 indicators
China Monitoring Report
This comprehensive approach aims to provide a clearer picture of China's economy.
the 50 indicators, we can get a more comprehensive image of a Chinese economy
trade surplus
over 1.2 trillion US dollars USD
record trade surplus for last year
A high trade surplus indicates strong export performance but may mask underlying domestic economic weaknesses.
China ran a trade surplus of over 1.2 trillion US dollars, the largest in history.
social_protests
steady rise in social protest since the pandemic
Trends in social unrest in China
Increasing protests signal growing discontent with governance and systemic issues.
it shows that a steady rise in social protest since the pandemic
debt
60 to 70% of GDP
official debt level
Understanding the official debt level is crucial for assessing economic stability.
the debt is about 60 to 70% of GDP
Key entities
Timeline highlights
00:00–05:00
China's increasing opacity complicates the understanding of its economic and social conditions, particularly with the challenges posed by the great firewall. The Thinking Taiwan Foundation aims to provide insights into these dynamics while fostering international dialogue on Taiwan's future.
- Chinas increasing opacity complicates the tracking of developments within the country. The great firewall and tighter controls over information hinder firsthand reporting, obscuring the true economic and social conditions
- Despite a reported record trade surplus in 2025, Chinas economic reality is complex. Strong export figures mask underlying issues that require deeper analysis
- The Thinking Taiwan Foundation serves as a public forum for dialogue on Taiwans future, focusing on policy, geopolitical economy, and societal issues related to monitoring China
- Thinking Taiwan 2.0, initiated by former President Tsai Ing-wen, emphasizes long-term trend analysis over day-to-day policymaking. This shift reflects a strategic approach to Taiwans development
- The foundations China Monitoring Project provides insights into Chinas internal dynamics and aims to foster international dialogue, ensuring Taiwans perspectives are recognized globally
- By emphasizing openness and communication, the foundation seeks to engage both domestic and international audiences. This approach is vital for enhancing Taiwans visibility and influence
05:00–10:00
The China Monitoring Report tracks 50 indicators across various sectors to provide insights into China's internal dynamics. This annual project aims to identify long-term trends and may include topic-specific indicators in the future.
- The China Monitoring Report tracks 50 indicators across economy, finance, society, and politics, providing a systematic approach to observing Chinas internal dynamics. This annual project emphasizes continuity in monitoring changes over time to identify long-term trends
- The research team consists of specialists with extensive fieldwork experience and economists who use standardized indicators for a comprehensive understanding of Chinas complexities
- Future developments of the report may include topic-specific indicators, such as assessing Chinas potential transition to a wartime economy or the lack of political democratization despite economic growth
10:00–15:00
Professor Yifen Tao's research on China has evolved from a time of openness in the 1990s to a current climate of increased security concerns and reluctance among locals to share their experiences. This shift complicates the ability of scholars and journalists to conduct research and gather insights about China's socio-economic landscape.
- Professor Yifen Taos journey in China studies began in the early 1990s while pursuing her PhD at Columbia University, focusing on Zhu Rongjis banking reform during a time of openness in China. After her studies, she contributed to establishing Chinese studies centers at National Qinghua University and National Taiwan University
- Currently, many scholars, including Tao, find it difficult to conduct research in China due to security concerns and a lack of willingness from locals to discuss their experiences. This reflects a significant shift from the openness of the 1990s and highlights the challenges faced by journalists covering China
15:00–20:00
China's economy is characterized by strong exports and weak domestic consumption, with exports constituting about one third of GDP. The country recorded a trade surplus of over 1.2 trillion US dollars last year, while deflationary pressures and low consumer confidence hinder domestic spending.
- Chinas economy exhibits a dual-speed reality, with strong exports contrasting weak domestic consumption. Exports make up about one third of GDP, leading to a record trade surplus of over 1.2 trillion US dollars last year
- Weak consumption is evident as prices remain flat or decline, causing people to save rather than spend. This behavior results in a shrinking private investment sector and ongoing deflationary pressure
- Deflationary trends indicate that even government interest rate adjustments fail to stimulate consumer spending, exacerbating the economic situation. The widening gap between M1 and M2 money supply shows liquidity trapped in savings, reflecting low consumer confidence
- Chinas aggressive export strategies face skepticism from households and private firms, leading to reluctance in investment and spending. This suggests that the perceived strength of the economy may be misleading
- The structural downturn indicates a long-term dependence on exports for growth, which may not be sustainable as global demand for Chinese goods could decline. Trade frictions are expected to rise as countries react to the influx of cheap Chinese products
20:00–25:00
China's low domestic consumption, at only 13% of production, is contributing to global deindustrialization, impacting industries worldwide. Social unrest is rising, reflecting a shift from economic grievances to broader systemic issues and declining living standards.
- Chinas low consumption, which is only 13% of its production, is causing global deindustrialization as countries struggle against cheap Chinese exports, leading to industry closures similar to the US rust belt
- Social indicators show a rise in protests since the pandemic, reflecting a shift from economic grievances to broader issues of systemic unfairness and government abuse of power
- Marriage and birth rates in China are at historical lows, signaling a silent protest and a growing discontent with the system as citizens question the effectiveness of governance amid declining living standards
25:00–30:00
China is experiencing a liquidity trap, leading to stagnation as consumers and firms prioritize saving over spending. The government's reliance on budget deficits and hidden debts raises concerns about the long-term stability of the economy.
- Chinas liquidity trap is causing consumers and firms to save rather than spend, leading to stagnation in the real economy. This situation is exacerbated by banks favoring government bonds over lending to businesses
- Despite a seemingly stable financial system, Chinas government control indicates underlying instability. The focus on maintaining stability over growth raises concerns about the long-term viability of the economy
- Chinas official debt appears manageable at 60 to 70% of GDP, but hidden debts could inflate this figure to 100 to 120%. This situation poses significant risks to the governments ability to manage its liabilities
- The Chinese governments reliance on budget deficits and avoidance of bankruptcies for state-owned and private firms creates a precarious financial environment. This could lead to sharp increases in future deficits
- For Taiwan, systematic monitoring of Chinas developments is essential to avoid panic or complacency in policy-making. Accurate assessments of Chinas trends are critical for informed decision-making
- Reactive policy-making in Taiwan, which responds only to Chinas actions, is risky. A proactive approach, informed by systematic monitoring, enables Taiwan to craft creative policies rather than merely reacting